12/27/2023 0 Comments Red herring fallacy 2016I would like to examine three types of fallacy that have been particularly pertinent to the presidential election thus far, and hopefully through increased awareness and understanding of these logical blunders we can all take a step toward making an informed decision this November. I’m sure the vast majority of people taking the time to read this have heard of fallacy and have a sound understanding of it, but I’m afraid the voters and media of our country have either forgotten or chosen to ignore fallacies this election season. But when you meet the new manager, you’ll understand.Logical fallacy is defined by Oxford English Dictionary as “a failure in reasoning which renders an argument invalid.”Ĭontrary to the title, I’m not writing this because I want to give an English lesson. And, really, who doesn't like warmer weather? The weather will definitely be a plus."Įxplaining why a company made an outside hire - “We know that many people here wanted the promotion and are disappointed in our decision. Do note that we continue to provide lunches at a standard cost in the cafeteria, and we know what a huge benefit that is for most workers!"Īrguing in favor of moving to another state - "Sure, South Carolina is quite a distance from Maryland, but it is better for our business model. It's important for us to note that the product we create is exceptionally flawless and we thank our manufacturing department for that.”Īdvocating an increase in health care contributions from employees - "We are going to be forced to increase the amount of your contribution to your health care costs by 10%. We try to ensure the best customer service, too."ĭefending layoffs - "Unfortunately, we have to lay off 5% of the workforce. You know, we work really hard to make a good product. You’re sure to find examples of the red herring fallacy in the workplace when:Īrguing against giving raises - "Sure, we haven't given raises in over five years to our employees. What we need is economic growth that can only come from the hands of leadership."īusiness Examples of the Red Herring Fallacyīusiness leaders and companies are experts at making bad news sound good, even if they have to completely change the subject in order to do so. Let's support children."ĭefending one's own policies regarding public safety - "I have worked hard to help eliminate criminal activity. Sometimes they are linked, sometimes they are not, but only time will tell."Īrguing for raising taxes - "We need more revenue to support the programs that we have. However, let's consider that the weather has changed as well. What we should really discuss is my record on votes that expanded educational opportunities for all children."ĭefending one's inaction in regards to increased crime - "The crime in this city has, in fact, increased lately. What is really important is to talk about whether the government has enough cash flow to stay open through the month."ĭefending one's voting past - "While you may have concerns about my votes about the environment, I can assure you that I am an open-minded individual. Politicians may employ this tactic when:Īvoiding discussing a delicate topic - "I understand you want to know what happened at the embassy. In public speaking, this technique is called a pivot - but practiced rhetoricians know that it’s actually just a red herring. You’ve seen it a hundred times before: someone asks a politician a direct question, and in the blink of an eye, they’re talking about something else. But have you heard about the new sushi restaurant just across the street? It’s supposed to be amazing!” Do you want to see pictures?”Ĭhanging plans - “We could definitely go to the pizza place for dinner. It’s in the same location as my wedding, which was so fun because I invited my whole family and all my friends and we partied all night long. Turning the conversation around to yourself - “I’m so excited for your wedding. Getting out of trouble - “Why are you pulling me over for speeding? Shouldn’t you be out catching the real criminals? Someone could be robbing a bank as we speak!” Rationalizing a purchase - “Yes, I bought an RV without your permission, but look at the trip I’ve already planned! We’ll have so much fun!” Don’t you love coffee?”Ĭomplaining about prices - “How can you charge that much for a burrito? Don’t you care about people who are hungry and can’t afford a gourmet burrito?” Let’s go home and see what fun toys we have there!”Ĭonvincing a parent to lend you the car - “I know you don’t want me to borrow the car, but I was going to pick up coffee for you. More everyday examples of the red herring fallacy include:ĭistracting a child - “You’re right, that toy in the toy shop looks really fun. Have you ever complained about your day and someone jumped in to say “You think that’s bad? Try commuting for two hours in the pouring rain!” Congratulations - you’ve just found a red herring in the wild.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |